Well, after making Eric his own short sleeved button up shirt I got jealous and decided it was time to make my own. After looking at so many patterns of different button ups (been on my mind since Oct 2024!) I landed on the Bellbird Button Up by Australian pattern company Common Stitch. Really all it took was seeing two great Bellbird button ups on Instagram to seal the deal for me! This one by Bethany of @soberseamstress (she’s also the owner of Fluid Plus Drape) and this one by Emily of @ermthewormsews. Aren’t they both great? I hadn’t heard of this pattern company before seeing those two shirts. I liked the cropped sizing and boxy look and thought the box pleat on the back was a nice detail too. Before I get into allll the details, here’s the cost breakdown of my shirt:
- Pattern: $6.16 (Normally $12.21 but I had a 10% off shop coupon ($1.22) and used $4.83 from the remainder of an Etsy gift card)
- Fabric: $21 for 1.5 yards
- Buttons: $2.00
- Pattern Printing: $4.97
Total spent: $34.13
(A pink cotton Gutermann thread and weft Interfacing were already in my stash, I’m not going to include those in the total pricing.)
Roughly $35 for materials really isn’t bad in my book! This shirt is going to get a ton of wear.
The Fabric & Buttons
Back in February I purchased 2.5 yards of this Cabana Stripes Sunburst fabric by Diamond Textiles from Seams Like Quilting in Spooner, WI. I purchased it without a plan and after staring at in my sewing space for months I decided I finally needed to use it, and use it NOW. It’s a medium weight, yarn dyed shot cotton. It feels sturdy, durable but not rough. I really love it and am glad I used it for a shirt since I don’t have something like it in my closet already.
I really went back and forth on what buttons to use. Part of me wanted to go simple and traditional with these shell buttons I thrifted the same weekend I bought my fabric. Part of me also really wanted to use some of my ridiculous buttons I got from the Textile Center garage sale. After doing a poll on Instagram (where the results were really split) my husband tipped the scales over to the white buttons made from shells. I also honestly haven’t sewn a shank button before and that little extra work on looking up a how to (lol I’m sure it’s super easy) also had a hand in me going with the shells (I just wanted to finish the dang shirt!). I like the white ones but I don’t know, do you think I should’ve gone with the fun option?
Things To Consider
Since Common Stitch is an Australian pattern company, their measurements are in metric. I want to emphasize it is not a big deal to do the conversion from metric to imperial, but you do have to do the math when figuring out sizing and how much fabric. The seam allowances are in cm and mm.
I ran into a problem with printing the pattern as it’s formatted for A4 printer paper which is slightly narrower and slightly longer than US letter. You can’t just do “print to fit” as that will throw off the sizing. I think I could’ve gotten around this using US legal printer paper but instead opted to have my pattern printed at Sewing Lounge over in St. Paul (which, HOT TIP: it’s the cheapest spot I’ve found in the Twin Cities for large format A0/copy shop pattern printing at $3/page! The turn around was incredibly fast too ). 1 Another thing to consider is that when I opened the pattern in Acrobat I found that they didn’t layer their sizes so I couldn’t “turn off” printing the sizes I didn’t want. You’ll have to print all the size lines.
This pattern has a lot of ease; it’s meant to be a boxy top. I made an Aus size 14 (roughly a US 10) even though my measurements had me at a 16 for the bust, 18 for the waist and 14 for the hips. I’m so happy I didn’t go any higher for the size and next time I would make a 14 again or maybe even size down to a 12. When I hold out my arms you can see straight through those arm holes and see my bra, ope! However, I really do LOVE the length of this shirt, it’s perfect for me. The pattern also doesn’t have a lengthen/shorten line so I figure if you wanted to change that you would do so just at the bottom hemline? There is also an option to make this pattern with long sleeves, but it doesn’t have a traditional placket for the long sleeves.
Me? Issues? Always
On That Collar Stand
As this was my first go with a collar stand, I didn’t do the best job sewing it to the placket and just kind of had to do my best to jam it all in there. You’d have to be looking closely to notice, but I know and it does bother me some. I could try to fix it but I think I’ll just learn from my mistake and do a better job next time. I’m pretty sure this was my error and not the pattern. As it is so super thick up there I couldn’t use my buttonhole foot to make my top buttonhole. I left it as is, sewed the button on and figured I won’t really ever want to button that button. I didn’t even bother to sew a button and buttonhole on the collar stand. I may still fix the unfinished buttonhole but just haven’t attempted yet.
Pocket: Change?
Here’s a word of caution: don’t do what I did and attach the pocket first thing. I really wanted to pattern match the stripes and in previous shirts I’ve made with pockets they have you attach the pocket first thing. This pattern doesn’t have you do that and I quickly found out why–you have to fold over and sew down the length of the front to make a placket and that could interfere with the pocket. I should’ve read through all the instructions before starting, this could’ve been avoided. Look how dumb it is that I put my pocket so close to the placket! Ugh. Do I seam rip it and ruin my beautiful pattern matching though? I also honestly think the pocket should also be moved up. Maybe for the next one I don’t even add a pocket.
Details! The Best Part Of Sewing Your Own Clothes
I couldn’t make a custom label for Eric’s shirt and not make one for myself, right? I like all of the woven “Made In 2025” labels that you can buy but I’m hesitant to buy those–what if I don’t use them and then they’re obsolete?! Using my machine to make a custom one is the perfect solution. I once again just whip stitched this to the yoke; I opted not to sew interfacing to the back of the label this time and it seems fine without it.
I also almost always like a little hanging loop on a shirt. I took a small scrap and made one and sewed it down before sewing the collar in. Worked great!
Look At how the stripes on the back yoke almost perfectly line up with the stripes on the sleeve! Wish I could say that was intentional but I just lucked out. (No, they are not lined up at all on the other sleeve lol)
Lastly, isn’t the box pleat cute? I had never made one before and this turned out great. It was so easy but it’s also such a nice detail.
Final Thoughts
I love this shirt, despite the flaws and I’m proud to have it in my closet! I’ve only had it for a little over a week, have already spilled ketchup on it (and got it out) and have worn it probably 4 times. I I’m nearly positive I’ll make it again and will pay closer attention to the details of where I went wrong like the collar stand and pocket. I’d like to have one out of a drapier fabric, like a linen, to see what the sleeves do because with this shot cotton they stick out a little more. Now that I’ve got a couple short sleeve button ups done I think it’s time I consider making a long sleeve button up! Maybe the Closet Core Jenna?
As always, if you got this far thanks for coming along!
- The Sewing Lounge has some incredibly nice linens, hemps, poplins, sandwashed linen and other lovely high quality fabric, mostly for garment sewing. She (Maggy, the shop owner) doesn’t do online sales but you can get a nice feel for what she carries by looking at the site. I walked out of there with 2 yards of a super soft white sandwashed cotton with my printed pattern! ↩︎
A Perfect Sandwich 